Search for a podcast, browse episodes, and download MP3 files directly from the publisher's website. Every episode comes with a downloadable transcript - we generate one if the show doesn't provide it.

Djuna Perkins takes over the Norfolk County DA's office in January and says she'll find out what went wrong in Sandra Birchmore's case. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke join me to talk about whether a DA can fairly investigate her own office.Perkins says the federal…

Sandra Birchmore's jury sent a note saying it was in a deadlock, and the next afternoon it convicted Matthew Farwell of killing her and causing the death of her unborn son. Retired FBI Special Agent Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke, the former chief of the FBI's Counterintelligence Behavioral…

Matthew Farwell was convicted of killing Sandra Birchmore and her unborn son. That is the verdict. Yet the defense that jurors rejected depended in part on making Sandra’s private struggles central to the story. Tony Brueski and psychotherapist Shavaun Scott ask why a woman’s emotional pain so…

Jennifer Coffindaffer has a question about the Moselle crime scene: how do investigators know they captured everything when the property went back to the Murdaugh family so quickly? Tony Brueski puts that issue alongside the State's new response to a motion attacking the indictments that launched…

Imagine waiting through four weeks of testimony in the Matthew Farwell murder trial, only to hear the jury say it cannot agree. That is where Sandra Birchmore’s family stood before the jury returned with guilty verdicts on November 10. Tony Brueski follows those hours in order: two notes from…

How does a defense lawyer explain a pregnancy announcement, a locked door, and a defendant who never takes the stand? That was the challenge at Matthew Farwell’s federal trial over Sandra Birchmore’s death. Jurors have now returned guilty verdicts on both counts, but the defense’s closing tells us…

One juror can prevent a unanimous verdict. But can a judge remove that juror because everyone else reportedly disagrees? That question sits at the heart of Lindsay Clancy’s effort to stop a second murder trial after the September 4 mistrial.Tony Brueski and former prosecutor turned defense attorney…

Sandra Birchmore was someone who told people nearly everything. Prosecutors turned what she did not say into part of the case against Matthew Farwell. Then there is what was missing. Prosecutors described Sandra as someone who messaged people constantly about the smallest parts of her day. Their…

An unrecorded conversation. A death labeled suicide. And a federal prosecutor standing before jurors five years later describing what the first investigation missed. Those are not abstract complaints about policing. They are questions raised in testimony and closing arguments in the Matthew Farwell…

What separates a detective's bad information from testimony serious enough to invalidate an indictment? That question now sits in front of Judge Debra McCaslin as Alex Murdaugh prepares for another murder trial in South Carolina. His legal team has asked that four indictments be dismissed without…

Matthew Farwell’s defense called a former chief medical examiner to support its suicide theory. Then prosecutors questioned him about injuries and what might happen if someone did not fight back. It is the kind of exchange that can sound decisive in a courtroom clip—until you put the whole…

There was blood near Nancy Guthrie’s front door. There was footage of a masked person. And there were questions almost immediately about how the missing woman’s Tucson property was handled. Months later, a separate reported phone-data lead points back to January, before the suspected abduction. Are…